Tuesday, November 11, 2014

CALL Literary Reaction Journal 2

Reaction to My mistress' eyes are nothing like the sun.


Ⅰ. Summary

The poem I chose is "My mistress' eyes are nothing like the sun" by  William Shakespeare. The Sonnets of Shakespeare consists of 154 sonnets. This sonnet is No.130. It is written about a man's love for an imperfect woman. He realizes that his woman pales in comparison to a god or other extravagant things, but his love is rare. His love is true love for an earthly being, not a god or goddess.


Ⅱ. Reaction

1.Imagery

In the first line of the poem, Shakespeare compares his mistress with the sun. This sets the tone for the rest of the poem, a tone of sincerity and mockery. He says her eyes "are nothing like the sun", which might seem horrible, should translate literally. Creating a joke out of the idea that someone might actually compare a woman's eyes to the sun, Shakespeare mocks many common comparisons of his time. "If hair be wires, black wires grow on her head" illustrates this idea more crearly. The theme of this poem is beauty. I think that he emphasizes the beauty by not using metaphors.


2.Character

"Mistress" is The Dark Lady. She distinguishes itself from the Fair Youth(sonnets 1-126) by being overtly sexual in its passion. The distinction is commonly made in the introduction to modern editions of the sonnets. The Dark Lady is so called because the poems make it clear that she has black hair and dun coloured skin. As with the Fair Youth, there have been many attempts to identify her with a real historical individual. Lucy Negro, Mary Fitton, Emilia Lanier, and others have been suggested.


3.Metaphor

During Skakespeare's time, it was common to compare a lover to nature, such as the sun and beautiful flowers. Shakespeare took advantage of this and praised the beauty of his lover. When reading this poem at first, we guess that this woman is not so beautiful. However, at the end, no women rival his lover but nature is beyond her beauty, his lover is the most beautiful in the world. 


Ⅲ. General opinion

It is difficult for me to understand what Shakespeare to say. I think that being praised honestly is more happier than being praised by using metaphors. He means that his mistress cannot compare with anyone and that she is the most beautiful for him, but he seems cruel at first glance. I want to be plaised in this way sometime and want to be valued by somebody. I can be considered about love and beauty by his profound thinking. Beauty should not be compared. It is important to love anyone obediently.

8 comments:

  1. Hi, Suzuno.
    I was surprised that your reaction of character is dilated! I could deeply understood about character of its poem. I read it, and I thought it is difficult to understand for me, too. But it is nice and beautiful poem, isn't it?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I could understand this poem more because I went into its character. I think that it is very nice and beautiful!! Thanks:)

      Delete
  2. Hello! Suzuno.
    I wrote this poem too.But I can't undrstand like you. Your blog read, was able to read in a new perspective. Thank you!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hello!
    I know Shakespeare's poems is difficult to understand or image, but I read your summery, imagery and so on I could image the poem. I was impressed your words, "Beauty should not be compared. It is important to love anyone obediently." Your senses are very nice!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you for your comment!!
      I'm glad that you can image the poem. It is difficult to understand, too.

      Delete
  4. Hi, I'm Megumi.
    I'm intereated that Shakespeare compare the woman he loves to sun and beautiful flower.
    He may felt her these. It is very passionate!
    I want to read Shakespeare' poems more!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you for your comment.
      This poem is passionate. It shows his strong love for her.
      Shakespeare's poems are great!

      Delete
  5. Hi, Suzuno.
    I have read this poem . This poem is very complicated. It was difficult to understand author's feelings in this poem.
    But, Your reaction is very detail. I want to emulate you.

    ReplyDelete